Reply to thread

Thanks everyone, I appreciate your comments and constructive feedback.  I agree that my edited images may be a tad over saturated, but I don't think that the image is unpleasant or unfaithfull to the original.  The reason I asked is that I was heavily criticised by a person in another group (local facebook photography group I'm in), who said my images were awful and artificial.  This is the same person who criticised my street photograph about a month ago of the people exercising in public on the heath.  The only time she comments on my images is to say how bad they are.  While I think whether you like something is down to your particular taste, and I don't mind negative but constructive comments (that is afterall how we learn), perhaps she is not justified in saying the image is awful, artifical and fake.