Welcome to Our Sony Alpha Shooters Forum

Be apart of something great, join today!

f1.2 is it all that?

View the Latest Sony Lens Deals At: B&H Photo

Unframed Dave

Veteran Member
Pro Member
Pro Member
Followers
13
Following
4
Joined
Jun 7, 2022
Posts
1,842
Likes Received
2,535
Trophy Points
313
Name
Dave
This is going to get a bit wordy, for me anyway.

I recently treat my good lady and I to four days in the city of light. I should stress that we were taking in a couple of shows in the evening, so low light shooting was a possibility.

I wanted to travel fairly light and so, initially I pondered the A7CR with my 24-70. This lens doesn't make for either a light or compact combination.

I then considered a nice little relatively fast 35 from Samyang. Very light, very compact and wouldn't be a disaster if the samyang got nabbed or damaged. It is a very cheap lens.

Then, I realised that I would miss my A1 and this gnawed away at my inner ear for a few hours.

I checked to see if it would fit in my trendy manbag. It did and left plenty of room for headphones and a still to be read paperback.

Size and weight, no longer being an issue, I opted for the Sony 50mm f1.2 GM, and found that this too would fit. Happy days.

When we got off the bus at Montmatre and the Moulin Rouge came into sight, I became frustrated with the lack of zoom ring on the lens. I'd also deliberately left all my other lenses at home, so I had to move my butt around and wait patiently for a gap in the traffic and all the bloody tourists.

As I wandered around the cemetery at Montmatre, something happened. I slowed down, and I pondered more. Light, shadow, colour and death. Sorry, you can't help but consider your mortality when you're surrounded by the deceased.

I started enjoying the lens, how deliberately, you had to consider everything. f1.2 is both brilliant and flaw revealing simultaneously. You have to be very aware when using it.

Over the next few days, I really did enjoy using it, but the experience wasn't always pleasant. Paris has many facets, and one that cannot be ignored, is that not everyone is out to make your day a pleasant one. It's a big lens, and it's expensive and looks that way. It attracts a lot of attention and in some places, I wished I'd chosen something more pedestrian. We survived though, she who must be obeyed is small and I think that makes people wary of her.

At the end of the day, all this waffle is leading to, would I have been fine with a 1.4 or even a 2.8?

Lighter, more compact, less noticeable. All good points for travel.

Did I need an extra fraction of a stop of light? Is the bokeh that distinctive? And, in the less savoury parts of the city, I could have slipped it in my pocket.

I guess the answer is blatantly obvious, but ultimately, I loved using that lens and wouldn't hesitate to grab it for a similar situation again. Exactly the same for the A1, it's familiar to me and fits my hand like my wedding ring.

I guess that's my point. Sometimes the answer isn't obvious, it's a shade of grey, much like photography.
 
Last edited:
Dave, this is a wonderful narrative that highlights many of my favorite photographic challenges.

I will frequently declare a given day or outing to be a 'prime day' (sorry Amazon) or 'prime outing'. Zooming lenses are wonderful, but can make us lazy. Primes force us to move our butts and more carefully consider framing and context. And if you really want a challenge, use a lens that doesn't support auto-focus. Now you really have to consider your shots!

I have yet to travel extensively with my gear but I will no doubt suffer the same angst of 'what camera and lens do I take'?. Will it be too heavy? Will it be too difficult to store or conceal?

And then it's the battle of the apertures. I tend to over-analyze which lens is best but when all is said and done, I realize that I was wasting my time. Usually, good enough is more than enough to properly capture the moment. I doubt anyone will ever look an image of mine and declare "This would have been sooooo much better if only he had used a f/1.2".

It sounds like you have a nice trip!
 
Very good points brought up here regarding fast aperture prime lenses!

I've been going back and forth between primes vs zooms for travel for several years now. Many of my concerns, issues, and experiences are very similar to the ones posted by Dave.

Perfect examples:

- A few years ago I went on a road trip from Florida to New Mexico. I thought I had packed all my important gear in a couple of camera bags. Halfway through the trip (somewhere in mid Texas), I went to grab my gear from one of my camera bags only to discover that I had forgotten to actually pack my gear into the camera bags! The bags were empty! I was so focused on deciding what camera bags to use that I had forgotten to pack them with my camera gear! Luckily I happen to have an old "beater" dslr with a 24mm f2.8 prime that I carried for daily use. I ended having no choice but to use that single camera with that single lens on my 3000 mile road trip. I did get some nice images but missed many possible shots due to lack of longer/wider lenses.

- A couple of years ago I accompanied my kid to Iceland. All I took was a mirrorless body and three primes. Thanks to the extremely painful cold weather, the only lens I used was a 24mm prime (again). It was too cold to change lenses, and the rain made it even more difficult. I really wish I would have had either a 16-35mm f2.8 or a 24-70mm f2.8 instead of the three primes I took with me.

Since then, I purchased a few "super zooms" and wide angle zooms for travel (Tamron 17-28mm f2.8, 20-40mm f2.8, 28-200mm f2.8-5.6). What I noticed was that most of my images from recent trips were between 17mm and 35mm. Why carry longer lenses when I mostly shoot at two focal lengths? So, I've been restructuring my travel camera outfit to go back to primes (yet again). For the sake of less weight, I'm considering just traveling with primes. However, the problems are missing shots due to not having the right focal length, dust on the sensor thanks to changing lenses constantly, extra weight/extra space taken up in my camera bag.

Bottom line, the only solution is to accept some sort of compromise. I love my fast primes (especially my Sony 35mm f1.4 GM), but a somewhat fast f2.8 zoom is way more practical. But that f2.8 zoom (be it a 16-35mm f2.8 or a 24-70mm f2.8) will be considerably heavier.
 

* Please Consider Becoming a Site Supporter To Remove These Ads *

I had a bit of a chuckle at the story about the road trip. It has made me want to do another.

I did Orlando to Key West in a black Camaro a few years back and loved every minute of it.

Just looked at the map and am now contemplating Miami to Mexico city. It looks awesome on the map.

I won't be doing it for a couple of years, but would it be an issue to take a hire car over the border?

Getting back to photography, my major issue with lenses and luggage is that I either tend to shoot street or wildlife. I'm no good at anything in between, so she who must be obeyed (Rumpole of the Bailey, in case you're not familiar) does all that.

I will be off shortly and carrying both a 600 f4 and a 24-70 f2.8, nothing else really gets much use. I'm heading much closer to the equator, so fast lenses for light tend to be immaterial. Image quality and feel are what I'm looking for. You can look at tens of thousands of images of a small bird singing it's heart out, but the one that has always stuck in my head is taken by Simon d'Entrement. I can picture it now without Google and my memory is truly appalling. I'll see if I can link it below. Anyway, it's moments like that that I'm looking for these days.

 

View the Latest Sony Lens Deals At: B&H Photo

Back
Top