Welcome to Our Sony Alpha Shooters Forum

Be apart of something great, join today!

Birds Looking for opinions on crop or not

AlphaWorld

Veteran Member
Pro Member
Pro Member
Followers
13
Following
0
Joined
Apr 8, 2021
Posts
1,769
Likes Received
1,369
Trophy Points
213
Name
Tony
I visited Werribee Zoo to see the cats - lions and cheetahs. I do see birds through the glass at the lion enclosure - often they are raptors.

Because I was here to photograph the lions I had the 50-150mm f/2 on the A1 II - not a typical bird set up.

Today a raptor came rather closer than usual, and I got a burst of shots that I liked. I want to get your opinion on the better way to present a couple of them.

So here are the uncropped shots (scaled to 2000pixels for this site). The bird is not huge in the frame, but we get to see the (out of focus) framing.

First frame: 50-150mm at 150mm f/2 1/5000 ISO 100 (bright sunshine):
A12225222f2k.jpg


And here's the second shot (it was the next shot from the burst. Exactly the same settings.
A12225223f2k.jpg


Now, normally I crop to make the bird a larger part of the image. So here are the cropped versions of these same images.

A12225222cc2k.jpg


A12225223cc2k.jpg


So, my question is: do you prefer the originals, or the crops? And, if you don't mind, can you why?
 

* Please Consider Becoming a Site Supporter To Remove These Ads *

I prefer the second shot in each group. And between them, I prefer the cropped version. The branches seem to do a better job framing the bird.
 

New in Marketplace

Back
Top